Perfect Day


Perfect Day (Lou Reed, 1972).
Perfect Day (BBC promotional film, 1997).

In an ideal world, it probably wouldn’t be necessary for the BBC to advertise itself like this.

Jane Frost, 1999.

Blame Trainspotting: Lou Reed’s “Perfect Day,” arranged and produced in 1972 by Mick Ronson and Bowie, had a second life a quarter of a century later, thanks in part to Danny Boyle’s film. As Boyle used it to score a heroin overdose sequence, “Perfect Day” was subsequently interpreted by an entire generation as being a song about scag.

Sure, maybe it was: you could read the song that way. But it’s more interesting to take “Perfect Day” at its word. An alienated, drugged-out wastrel spends a day in the park with his girlfriend or boyfriend. He does “normal” things—goes to a zoo, sees a film, has a picnic—which seem surreal to him. His life is so bent out of shape, his way of viewing the world so corroded, that banal existence has become strange and beautiful. The perfect day for him is one that the good and prosperous people of the world would forget about in a week. And what to make of the closing line? You’re going to reap just what you sow, Reed sings sweetly and ominously. Has he reformed? Or is he just clearing his head to ruin his partner’s life with greater force?

A few months after the first Labour parliamentary victory in nearly 20 years, the BBC made a celebration and a justification of itself, a four-minute promotional film featuring the stars of pop, country, R&B, jazz (well, they got Courtney Pine) and classical. All singing lines from “Perfect Day.” The promo film was masterfully shot and cut (Simon Hanhart produced the music), making a smooth whole out of what could have been an ungainly patchwork. There was a clamoring for the track to be released as a single, and soon enough it was, with all proceeds going to Children in Need: it would be Bowie’s last (collaborative) #1.

Jane Frost, the BBC’s head of corporate marketing, was the force behind it. After tenures in marketing for Lever Brothers and Shell, Frost was recruited by the BBC in 1995: her main job was to explain the service’s role to a new generation, using the language of pop videos and advertisements. The BBC had just won a battle to raise its license fee (the fee for color TVs would increase from £71 in 1990 to £104 in 2000) and in Frost’s words, it wanted to remind viewers what they would miss if it ever went away (“if it disappeared, you really would be losing something”).*

Assembling an all-star cast to sing Reed’s “Perfect Day” was Frost’s first big set-piece. “The production values are high, because we want to catch people’s attention—they’ve got to be a cut above the standard of the old public information films,” she told the Guardian in 1999. “But you’d be surprised how cheaply you can make something when the goodwill is there.” Most performers accepted standard minimum Equity payments of £250, while Bowie went one further: he waived his fee, citing the “years of pleasure” given to him by The Flower Pot Men.

reaping what you sow

As for the production itself, it’s easy enough to criticize: its overstuffed wedding cake of an arrangement, the pomposity of some of its performers (Bono, giving off a comfortable smugness here, takes the crown, though Huey Morgan is a viable contender), its inadvertent comic moments (Reed apparently doing a Stevie Wonder impersonation; a ludicrous Evan Dando cameo). For Bowie fans, his two lines, which he sings with a trace of wry bemusement, was evidence that Bowie should’ve covered the song himself, though there’s no evidence he ever considered it.

Still, of all the Bowie collaborations, “Perfect Day” contains the greatest amount of sheer vocal talent (Tammy Wynette, Heather Small, Emmylou Harris, Gabrielle) and it’s the only Bowie duet, if only by montage, with the likes of Brett Anderson, Boyzone, Dr. John, Shane MacGowan (appearing with great comic timing) and Tom Jones, the latter filmed singing “you’re gonna REEEAAAAP” as if auditioning for the part of Galactus.

Amid all the exquisitely-framed shots and cheery goodwill and sense of “culture,” was there someone forgotten? The man from Hull who, sitting down and hearing Reed play “Perfect Day” on guitar at Trident Studios, had suggested it would work better as a piano song? And who’d then played the piano line himself, and later scored the strings? So take the Beeb’s “Perfect Day” for whatever you’d like—as a fine or a ludicrous spectacle, as a pleasant way to support charity, as a latter-day career boost for Reed, as a fine public service message. I’ll take it as a secret requiem for Mick Ronson; a world’s worth of performers unknowingly singing their respects to him.

Recorded ca. summer 1997 and released as a single on 3 October 1997 (Chrysalis CDNEED01, UK #1). (& so I’ve passed Tom Ewing at last (happy 10th birthday, Popular!)).

* In this context, a few critics at the time noted an implied threat in the increasingly ecstatic repeats of “you’re going to reap what you sow.”

Top: promo poster for Toby Mott’s “Made in London” exhibition, Maureen Paley Interim Art, autumn 1997.

19 Responses to Perfect Day

  1. Mr Tagomi says:

    I had no idea how talented or significant Mick Ronson was until I started reading this blog.

  2. Sinj says:

    always loved Brett Anderson’s little contribution to this.

    Some of the rest is awful, but Bowie and Brett do a nice job.

    There’s some good footage of bowie larking around practising his bit for the video somewhere – will try and find it…

  3. Sinj says:

    here it is!

    • Maj says:

      Ooh, thanks. Bowie larking around never gets old – and this particular bit is actually completely new to me. Ha!

      • Mark Shark says:

        If you’re up for a bit of Bowie larking around see this bit:

        There’s three parts to this but I have yet to find part one. cheers

  4. MC says:

    Forgot about this one! Really partial to this; close to the cream of the crop as far as all-star charity benefit records go. I’m guessing this is Lou’s only #1 record as well. Least-favourite moment is that Huey guy’s contribution; he blows the song’s most poignant moment for me. Tom Jones kinda ruins the outro,I suppose, but he’s enjoyable as well. He really only has one setting, doesn’t he (i.e. BLASTINGLY LOUD).

    This version of Perfect Day really makes it the Christmas standard it always had the potential to be (and that’s actually not a criticism). Great accompaniment while you sob into your eggnog. 🙂

  5. Patrick says:

    “Tom Jones, the latter filmed singing “you’re gonna REEEAAAAP” as if auditioning for the part of Galactus.” That really made me laugh out loud (or LOL as the youngsters say.)

    A couple years later in a now gone vinyl only record shop near me I picked up Lou Reed’s “Walk on the Wild Side” single and to my surprise on the B side was “Perfect day”.

  6. Maj says:

    That’s a nice way of looking at this, a requiem for Ronno. I’ll take that.

    Well, I rarely listen to this version (Bono.) but as charity collabs go it’s among the best, in my opinion.

    Don’t think I’ve ever seen the video. I even had no idea it was a BBC promo before becoming CIN single. It used to be played on our radios a LOT. And it still pops up from time to time.

  7. The Ziggurat says:

    Ha! Out of the XXXX-thousand songs for my iPod to hit on shuffle while checking (GoRead-Google Reader), “Perfect Day” came on right before I saw the title of this post. Timely!

    I will admit – I’m part of the latter-generation, the millennial who had never heard “Perfect Day” until I saw Trainspotting when I was 16 or so. And, it wasn’t until I got my own copy of The Complete David Bowie that I realised Bowie & Ronson had anything to do with Transformer.

    Great posts as always. You’re bound to see this name commenting more, as I’ve finally read every post/listened to every (sigh) Bowie song with the blog over the last 9 months, in an attempt to catch up.

    – V from Detroit, MI

  8. Mother says:

    Well said. Mick Ronson is a God

  9. Reba says:

    Someone seems to be putting off listening to “… hours”

  10. Brendan O'Lear says:

    Putting off listening to “…hours” is usually the best strategy.

    On the other hand, it’s always a good idea to make tenuous links to Mick Ronson. For such a guitar hero, so much of his best studio work was with piano and strings. Somehow he got to that ‘perfect’ arrangement from demos like this:

    • Reba says:

      The “.. hours” comment was just a joke. I’ve been enjoying the posts on the non-album performances.

  11. ric says:

    PD was on the B-side of Walk on the Wild Side (UK 7″). You got value for money in them days.

    • Brendan O'Lear says:

      And you also got some very strange commercial decisions from RCA.
      Perfect Day didn’t even make the RCA mid-seventies Lou Reed’s greatest hits compilation, and that was one that really tested the length of their barrel-scraper.

  12. s.t. says:

    Rest in peace, Lou.

    • MC says:

      I second that emotion. Goodbye, Lou. 😦

    • prankster36 says:

      I’m working my way through the blog–almost caught up to the present day–and it’s truly bizarre the confluence here: the day before he died I first witnessed that video game commercial currently using this song, and now the day after, I stumble across this. Both completely coincidental. Fuckin’ weird.

  13. fantailfan says:

    “Just a perfect day–You made me forget myself. I thought I was someone else. Someone good.” – LR, 1972

%d bloggers like this: