Turn Blue

Turn Blue (Pop and Bowie, live, 1977).
Turn Blue (Pop, 1977).

On paper, The Idiot and Lust For Life seem almost identical—both produced and performed by Bowie and Iggy Pop, with nearly all songs co-compositions. Yet Lust For Life is far more Pop’s record, with Bowie seemingly relegated to a supporting role (as during the spring 1977 Idiot tour, where Bowie just played keyboards and sang backup).

If Bowie seems a lesser presence on Lust for Life, it’s not for want of effort. The album sessions were a creative war between Bowie and Pop, with Bowie losing more of the battles. Bowie had written much of the music beforehand and had demoed it on cassettes, but Pop, coming off a triumphant tour and far more confident than he had been during The Idiot sessions, had grown irritated by Bowie’s control-freak tendencies—Bowie had kept the master tapes of The Idiot, and had pushed RCA to issue Low two months before it (so critics assumed Pop’s record was responding to Low, and not (as it was in truth) the other way around).

So making Lust For Life, Pop often rejected Bowie’s original arrangements and vocal melodies (see “Success”), instead pushing the band to put together something from scratch. Pop also had allies in the studio this time, as Bowie’s regular right-hand-man Carlos Alomar was matched by the second coming of the Stooges for a rhythm section: the brothers Hunt and Tony Sales.

The band (along with the lead guitarist Ricky Gardiner, who had come up with the riff for “The Passenger” during a springtime walk in the countryside) was hardened during the manic cross-Atlantic Idiot tour (29 shows in six weeks). Iggy’s set consisted of Stooges classics, a handful of songs from the album he was allegedly promoting (“Sister Midnight,” “China Girl” and “Funtime”) and three new, unrecorded numbers. At the two Rainbow Theatre shows in London, the punk vanguard paid homage to a godfather—milling backstage were Johnny Rotten, Brian James of the Damned, Howard Devoto (who gave Pop a copy of the Buzzcocks’ Spiral Scratch, saying “I have all of your records, now you have all of mine”), the Adverts, Billy Idol and Johnny Thunders, who worried that Bowie was making Pop “go cabaret.”

Pop hadn’t been on stage since October 1974, and the tour was his first-ever billing as a solo artist. He had something to prove, had a crack band and so kept a brutal pace, with the detox work Bowie and Pop had done in 1976 going by the board (“the drug use was unbelievable and I knew it was killing me,” Bowie said in 1993). After a brief recuperation in Los Angeles, Pop returned to Berlin, rented an apartment in the Tempelhof-Schöneberg district and in June 1977* made Lust for Life at Hansa Tonstudio 3.

“Turn Blue,” regularly played during the Idiot tour, is the oldest song on the record, a remnant from Pop and Bowie’s first disastrous attempt to record together in Los Angeles in May 1975. Originally called “Moving On” (co-written with Bowie’s old friend Geoff MacCormack**), it was revived for the 1977 tour, with the lyric greatly reworked by Pop and the LA-based artist Walter Lacey.

The rambling lyric is essentially Iggy Pop free-styling at the mic, with Bowie coming in afterward with vocal overdubs to sweeten things out and add structure to the song. (That said, Pop’s not improvising the lyric in the studio, as he had sung “Turn Blue” much the same way on stage months before). Over a seven-minute vamp, Pop rants, murmurs, squeaks, cries, gives comic asides (“Jesus? This is Iggy”); he gets snagged on lines and beats himself against them (“I shot myself down!” “They’re stepping on our hearts!” “BLACK!! STRONG!!” “Don’t forget me!”). It ends with the singer either shooting himself or shooting up: maybe it’s both.

Lust For Life is in part Pop channeling Jim Morrison—“The Passenger” was inspired by a Morrison poem, and “Fall In Love With Me” seems to be summoning his ghost—and there’s a taste of Morrison’s unhinged cod-poetic ramblings in “Turn Blue,” though Iggy’s weird, belligerent, pure Id of a vocal, the goofy intensity of his performance, makes what could have been a tortuous album-filler track into a piece of deranged performance art. When Bowie comes in on harmonies, the track even seems like a dark parody of the extended soul ballads from the Young Americans sessions.

Debuted ca. 1 March 1977 (the first extant live recording is from the Rainbow show of 7 March, while the recording linked above is from Detroit, 25 March). Recorded ca. 4-20 June 1977, Hansa, Berlin.

* Most early Bowie chronologies place the Lust For Life sessions in either April or May 1977. But Paul Trynka turned up records by Eduard Meyer at Hansa noting that some of the Lust sessions occurred on 8-12 and 14 June 1977. Most musicians involved recall that the album was cut in one go, in about 10 days, so a logical surmise is that Lust for Life was recorded ca. 4-20 June 1977.

** MacCormack, then known as “Warren Peace,” was Bowie’s closest friend, traveling companion and occasional collaborator (“Rock and Roll With Me”) from 1973 to 1976. MacCormack dropped out of the picture around the time of Low and little more was heard of him publicly (Pop said the split was because MacCormack “had become more Hollywood than was great for [MacCormack and Bowie’s] relationship,” though they seem to have patched up at some point in the ’80s). As for Lacey, the only other reference I could find of him was performing a spoken-word piece in 1982 called “Meatpack Man.”

Top: Simon Baddeley, “Street Party for the Silver Jubilee,” Edgbaston, Birmingham, 7 June 1977.

8 Responses to Turn Blue

  1. Jeremy Earl says:

    Yes, this track does something to me – great when you are drunk and perhaps split from some girl, the last of the red wine alone in the bottle at 2am, singing along. Maybe Johnny Thunders was right about his fears that Bowie was making Pop “go cabaret.”! Sounds like deranged cabaret to me. I can only imagine what the live version sounds like! I’ve always loved Bowie’s backup vocals in this track – restrained and pure, like some outsider trying to control the melodrama – ironic coming from Bowie. In fact Bowie’s backup vocals are usually great – see Perfect Day….

  2. Remco says:

    Probably my favourite song on Lust For Life, I love Iggy as a crooner.
    Now I’ve read each and every post on this blog (I only discovered it a couple of weeks ago)I’d like to compliment you on your amazing work. It’s the most intelligent writing on DB I’ve come across, you’ve got me hooked and I’d certainly buy the book.

    I’m assuming you’ve heard the newly leaked ‘Toy’ already and was wondering if you’ll be updating the posts on some of the older songs.

  3. Brendan O'Lear says:

    Not Iggy Pop’s biggest fan so I’ll try to refrain from excess negativity.
    As you mention Bowie has far less input here. It’s tempting to add, ‘… and it shows!’
    It’s difficult for me to conceive of any musical environment where the ridiculous Sales brothers could be any kind of match for Carlos Alomar.
    SInce it’s not a Bowie song and won’t be covered, The Passenger really is an incredible song and performance. Iggy Pop’s ‘monkey-typewriter- complete works of Shakespeare’ moment! OK, no more negativity from me!

  4. diamond dog says:

    I’ve just dug out my vinyl of lust for life and must say its a much more upbeat affair and I think the whole group sound like they having a riot. Its a great album and I can feel Bowie all over it it he and Pop superb on it as are the Sales brothers. Turn blue is the albums showstopper. I think Bowie could let go somewhat of the reins as the band were so tight after a tour. Its an easier album to like that Idiot and Turn blue shows a side of Pop as the crooner I like whilst Bowie is on top form with those backing vocals they send a shiver up the spine.

  5. Anonymous says:

    I love this song so much. Definitely and underrated gem. It really manages to perfectly capture the feeling of something dismantling yet still finding a way to be held together. It also showcases everyone at the height of what they do best. Bowie’s backup vocals are so sweet, and a perfect counter to Pop’s frenetic energy.

  6. WRGerman says:

    Geoff MacCormack, in his excellent book “From Station To Station” said that he dropped out of Bowie’s circle of his own volition (finding L.A. much too weird and druggy) and went back to the UK. Bowie apparently endorsed that version of events, as he consented to autograph each copy of the very limited Genesis Publication print run of the book.

  7. Danna Karro says:

    I do not know if it’s just me or if everybody else experiencing problems with your site. It appears as if some of the text in your content are running off the screen. Can someone else please provide feedback and let me know if this is happening to them as well? This might be a problem with my internet browser because I’ve had this happen previously. Many thanks|

  8. Matthew says:

    No problems with Firefox (windows 7 and 8.1) or Microsoft Edge for windows phone. Always displays perfectly and I can resize how I like.

%d bloggers like this: