The Prettiest Star

The Prettiest Star (single).
The Prettiest Star (Aladdin Sane remake).

Space Oddity” gave David Bowie a hit single at last and he had no clue how to follow it up. He dithered for months, considering “Janine,” among other Space Oddity tracks. The decision finally came down to either remaking “London Bye Ta-Ta” (his manager Ken Pitt’s choice) or cutting a new song that Bowie allegedly had just written for Angela Barnett, who he’d marry in a few months. Bowie went with the latter and got his old rival/colleague and emerging pop star Marc Bolan to play lead guitar on it. “The Prettiest Star” was simple, hummable, sweet and reassuring: it sold less than 800 copies.

Why did “The Prettiest Star” stiff so badly? Tony Visconti had warned about the danger of “Space Oddity”: it was such a dated one-off song that it threatened to consign Bowie into the bin of late ’60s novelties. Bowie resisted the obvious course, doing an SF-themed follow-up, but “Prettiest Star,” compared to “Oddity,” was quite square, its sentiments treacly, its tone warm and nostalgic. Many ’70s pop listeners would have a yen for those very qualities, but maybe March 1970 was a bit too soon. By the spring Bowie was recording heavy metal songs.

“The Prettiest Star,” lovely and neglected, is in retrospect the first sign of a countercurrent in Bowie’s ’70s work. Seventies Bowie is remembered mainly for glam rock anthems and “avant-garde” electronic records, for dressing as an alien or a Kabuki drag queen. But littered throughout all of that are the occasional regressions—stage ditties, warm reminiscences, tributes. Bowie followed his hard rock Man Who Sold the World LP with a return to music hall shenanigans, chased the sleazy glamour of Aladdin Sane with homage to his old Mod rivals and inspirations, and did a Christmas song with Bing Crosby while promoting “Heroes.”

“The Prettiest Star” has a basic verse-and-refrain structure, simple rhymes (“one day” with “someday”), dyslexic rhymes (“tried” and “tired”) and a pretty if unadventurous melody. There are a few tricks. Take the way the first three guitar notes serve as a count-in before the first bar of the intro, a pattern replicated before other verses by piano or strings. Or how in the first two verses Bowie stays on the C chord when it seems like he’s going to move up (“it can all but break your heart…in pieces,” “I moved up to take a place…near you”), only to break the pattern in the third verse, the chords moving to F and F7 as Bowie sings the title phrase. And the song’s other main part (the 10-bar section that begins “staying back in your memory“) is either a refrain or a bridge—it can serve either role.

All of this is overshadowed by the lead guitar, whose eight-bar intro is both overture for the verse (it’s the same underlying chords) and the song’s central motif. In the original version, the guitar intro reappears after two verses and is granted three more repetitions at the end—as a result, the track can feel like padding between a series of guitar solos. (When Bowie and Mick Ronson remade “Prettiest Star,” they corrected this flaw—the original’s draggy midsection, with two back-to-back bridges glued together by the repeated opening riff, is streamlined with the third verse now separating the two bridges and the riff repeat eliminated (the final guitar repeats are also reduced by one).)

“The Prettiest Star” seems to offer a battle of two lead guitarists—Marc Bolan on the single, Mick Ronson on the remake—but comparison listening makes it pretty clear that Ronson ceded the field to Bolan. While some critics have claimed Ronson reproduces Bolan’s solo note-for-note, which isn’t quite the case I think, he comes pretty close (Ronson even plays a vibrato-laden chord against Bowie singing “HOW you moved” in the bridge, just as Bolan did).

You can see why Ronson didn’t change it up: Bolan’s vibrato-saturated solo is one of the most melodic guitar lines he ever recorded, and it’s more memorable than Bowie’s vocal. In January 1970 Bolan only recently had switched to electric guitar (one reason he agreed to the Bowie session was that Visconti and Bowie had flattered his playing) and he plays the near-identical riff throughout the song, changing it only in the final repeat.

Ronson, when he remade “Prettiest Star” in late 1972, had his own well-established sound—plug his Les Paul directly into a cranked-up amp (occasionally using just a single wah-wah pedal), and, like Jimmy Page, use precise overdubs to fatten out the track (here he puts in a scratchy, distorted second guitar at the end of the intro). Bolan’s lead had been supplemented by Bowie strumming on 12-string acoustic guitar, but Ronson has no need of that, as saxophones serve to beef up the verses, freeing Ronson to craft metallic washes of sound.

It’s unclear why Bowie remade “Prettiest Star” for Aladdin Sane: perhaps he was short of new material (this was when record companies wanted artists to churn out new LPs seemingly every nine months—today, Justin Timberlake gets half a decade between records) and for most record buyers “Prettiest Star” was basically an unreleased track, given its awful reception in 1970.

If the original version of “Prettiest Star” was a simple valentine, the remake is a rowdy, garish engagement party, with doo-wop backing vocals, a horn section, an aggressive piano and a heavier beat. They both have their appeal, though the Aladdin Sane edition sounds like a better time.

Recorded 8, 13-14 January 1970 (with Visconti on bass and Godfrey McClean on drums) and released in March as Mercury MF 1135 c/w “Conversation Piece”—the same group, including Bolan, also cut “London Bye Ta-Ta” but it was left on the shelf; the Aladdin Sane remake was recorded in New York between 3-10 December 1972, in one of the first sessions for the LP.

Top: The Bowies wed each other, Bromley Registry Office, 19 March 1970.

10 Responses to The Prettiest Star

  1. Michael says:

    You know, it’a assumed that the song is about Angie but a song is really a poem and a poem is open to interpretation and can be about more than one person or thing. I wonder/suspect that Bowie had Marc Bolan in mind in the lyrics as well.

    Bowie has said that he and Marc Bolan met when they were painting Visconti’s office. It is pretty clear that Bowie was intensely competitive.

    The line “One day … you and I will rise up all the way, all because of what you are… the prettiest star.

    Well Bowie and Marc Bolan did “rise up all the way as glam rock stars and, speaking as a totally straight guy, Marc Bolan was very, very handsome – arguably the prettiest star. I had the pleasure of meeting Marc in ’72.

    I think therefore that Bowie may have had Marc Bolan in mind too, in Prettiest Star. A guess. My thought on it.

    I have a cool pic of T Rex with my brother on my facebook page, “Michael Jordan Rush” taken in a London clothing store in ’72. Feel fre to check it out. Marc was a sweet guy. He is missed.


  2. DAVIE says:

    Ronson proper owns that lead guitar, he does a far better job.
    Trust Marc Bolan’s wife to say to Bowie that “he doesn’t deserve to play on your record”….Bowie outlived and outdid Bolan in less than a few years after and he’s still here!

  3. Anonymous says:

    BOLAN did it far better than RONSON could ever, just my opinion as far as saying BOWIE outdid MARC i don’t think so.they are/were both glam rock icons! MARC BOLAN was idealized by DAVID BOWIE. TONY VISCONTI formed him into what he was.these two genius’s made DAVID BOWIE who he was back then and it still reflects on him to this day.if only BOLAN had more time to live!!!!!

  4. Frank says:

    I would have loved to read some words on the b-side, the original version of “Conversation piece”, which I love. I still like it more than the A-side… Thanks for your wonderfull blog!

  5. fantailfan says:

    I prefer the earlier version, now only available on the Sound + Vision comp. Most glam just sounds stupid to me, which may be be why it didn’t appeal to me at an age (11-12) when the difference between stupid and not-stupid became very important. Naturally, I went to prog.

    Anyway, I just finished the Rebel Rebel eBook. Now I’m at the stage where I’m flipping around it, listening to the song you are discussing, and trying to hear what you hear. It’s a tough job. I’ve been listening to this kind of music (“Rock”) since 1968. You disassemble it and put it back together again. Nice job.

  6. todd says:

    Cool cool song, very 70’s, fab time, me, still there, todd

  7. todd says:

    Like a rocket man, bowie’s cool cool song, well good well sound, love is lost remix, sweet, I’m all jazzed up, any cats out there? Todd

  8. todd says:

    Hot cold hot, hot to trot, quicksand takes me, I’m. Below, above below and dower, bang a drum, todd

%d bloggers like this: